Five Reasons The Rays Trail the Brewers 2-0-And What Must Change

Five Reasons The Rays Trail the Brewers 2-0-And What Must Change

By Ken Filler | Tampa Bay Sports Journal

ST. PETERSBURG — Two losses from the end. Four wins from a championship.

That is where the Tampa Bay Rays stand after a painful trip to Milwaukee to open the 2026 World Series.

The Brewers lead the series 2-0. The Rays must win four of the next five games to bring home their first championship. 

Games 3 and 4, along with Game 5 if needed, will be at Tropicana Field.

There is still a path. But the Rays have made it a whole lot harder than it needed to be.

These were two games Tampa Bay could have won. Instead, the Rays return home with nothing to show for it.

For those of us who have waited years to see this team finish the job, that hurts.

Here are five reasons the Rays are in this hole—and what must change.

1. They are leaving runs on the bases

Getting runners into scoring position is only half the job.

The Rays have given themselves chances. They have not done enough with them.

That is the difference between making a game interesting and winning it.

In a close World Series game, a runner at third cannot keep becoming a story about what might have been. 

A runner LOB is a blown opportunity in this high-stakes series. 

The Rays don’t need every hitter to hit a home run. 

Sometimes a fly ball deep enough to bring a runner home is plenty. 

Sometimes it takes a simple single.

I want to see the Rays make Milwaukee pay when it gives them an opening.

What must change: Stop letting good chances slip away. Put the ball in play with fewer than two outs and a runner at third. Take the walk when it is there. Make the next batter’s job easier.

The Rays need runs on the scoreboard. Almost does not count in October.

2. The offense has not kept the pressure on

The Rays scored four runs in the first inning of Game 2. Then they went quiet.

Milwaukee held the Rays scoreless over the final eight innings. The Brewers’ relievers handled six of those innings without allowing a run.

A four-run start should have been the beginning of a big night. Instead, it became the entire night.

Give Milwaukee credit. That bullpen has earned it.

But the Rays cannot let the Brewers settle in after one bad inning. Every empty inning gave Milwaukee another chance to catch up.

What must change: Keep building. Add a run in the middle innings. Give the bullpen a little breathing room. Make Milwaukee worry about more than protecting a one-run lead late.

Four early runs are great. A fifth might have changed everything Saturday.

3. The Seymour decision deserves scrutiny

Kevin Cash has helped get this team to the World Series. That doesn’t make his bullpen decisions any less questionable.

Going back to Ian Seymour in a big spot deserves a hard look.

My concern, going back to the Cleveland series, is that Seymour has not looked comfortable in these situations. 

Asking him to deliver again with a World Series game hanging in the balance was a gamble.

That is a criticism of the decision. It is not a claim that Seymour alone lost the game.

Plenty went wrong before and after the call to the bullpen. Still, a manager has to weigh what a pitcher is showing him right now.

October leaves little room to wait for things to turn around.

What must change: Cash needs to lean on the pitchers he trusts most to get the next out. 

If Seymour is struggling, find him a different spot.

The Rays can’t keep asking the same question and hoping for a different answer.

4. The defense is making the job harder

The Rays usually give themselves a chance by doing the small things well.

That includes catching the ball and finishing routine plays.

Jonathan Aranda’s defensive mistake helped Milwaukee close the gap in Game 2. Against a team that keeps coming, an extra chance can become an extra run.

And these games have been too close to give anything away.

The frustrating part is that the Rays do not need to become a different team. It needs to play the clean baseball that helped get it here.

What must change: Make the routine plays. Take the sure out. Avoid turning a manageable inning into a bigger problem.

You can’t give a team like the Brewers any runs. runs. Make them earn them. 

5. Milwaukee is finishing the games

The Brewers won the opener 3-2. They took Game 2, 5-4.

Two games. Two one-run losses.

That tells me the Rays can compete with this team. It also tells me Milwaukee has been better when the game is on the line and, as a result, has closed out both games. 

Sal Frelick tied Game 2 with a home run. Cooper Pratt later delivered the go-ahead hit. Tampa Bay threatened again but could not bring home the tying run.

Milwaukee has found the hit, the pitch, or the out it needed the most. 

The Rays have come up just short.

What must change: Somebody has to deliver the moment that turns a close loss into a win.

It could be a big hit. Maybe a reliever escaping trouble. It could be a clean inning that keeps the crowd roaring.

The Rays need to start by finishing one game. 

History is tough. Game 3 is the task.

History reminds us that a comeback is possible, but not very common. 

Through the 2024 World Series, ten teams had won the championship after losing the first two games: the 1955 Dodgers, 1956 Yankees, 1958 Yankees, 1965 Dodgers, 1971 Pirates, 1978 Yankees, 1981 Dodgers, 1985 Royals, 1986 Mets and 1996 Yankees.

The 1996 Yankees lost the first two at home to Atlanta, then won four straight.

The Rays return home to the friendly confines of Tropicana Field Monday Night for game three as the World Series resumes with Freddy Peralta starting for the Rays. 

The Rays do not have to win four games Monday. They have to win one.

Bring runners home. Catch the ball. Make better pitches when the game gets tight.

This season has given Tampa Bay too much hope to let it end with another string of missed chances.

There is still time to change the story.

But the Rays need to start writing a different ending in Game 3.

administrator
Ken Filler is the editor and founder of Tampa Bay Sports Journal, covering the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Tampa Bay Rays, Tampa Bay Lightning and USF Bulls. He provides original reporting, analysis and commentary on Tampa Bay sports, with an emphasis on games, roster moves and the stories shaping the local sports scene. Follow Ken on X at @krfiller64.

    Related Articles

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *